Lawyers | Poets | PoetryProfessor
James R. Elkins
College of Law :: West Virginia University Fall, 2006 Assignments Archive
We'll do some of the usual and customary things required to get a law school course underway. I'll try to respond to the following questions: What is the course? What is it all about? How did it come to be offered? What will I be required to do? Will I be asked to write poetry? Do I need to be a poet to take the course? Is this one of those courses that you need to be a literature major to take? Does the course have anything remotely related to being a lawyer and practicing law?
One must have some curiosity about the origins of Lawyers, Poets, and Poetry. I've attempted to provide an account of how I began my work on lawyer/poets and it may be of some interest to you as we begin the course.
The history of lawyer poets in this country is a venerable one; a history I hope you will aspire to learn something about. When I edited, what I take to be the first-ever collection of lawyers' poetry in 2004, my first inclination was to publish the poetry and only the poetry, and publish it without an introduction of any kind. Some of the poets who contributed to the issue argued against a historical publication of the kind I had compiled without a proper introduction. At the urging of some of the contributers to Off the Record: An Anthology of Poetry by Lawyers, I hesitantly set about to write an introduction.
I decided to write an introduction only when several of the contributors to the anthology convinced me that readers would be curious about the editor of such a collection and that I should, in some fashion, respond to the obvious questions: What in the world does he think he's doing in collecting and publishing these poems?
Since this is a course about poets and poetry, there'll be no better time than now to begin reading poetry. For our first class, I'd like you to peruse the poetry of contemporary lawyers (some in the active practice of law, some who have abandoned the legal profession for other pursuits). You'll find the poetry we read in course in three issues of the Legal Studies Forum. The most recent issue of LSF is being provided to you--compliments of of LSF--and you will have to purchase the issues published in 2004 and 2005. For our first class, I'd like for you to pick out two poems that you will be willing to read to the class, and that you will be willing to talk about. The poems need not be law-related. You'll need to think through, and be able to say something about your selection of the particular poems you've chosen. You don't have to explain your choice in any kind of formal or academic terms. You will be required to say something about what drew you to the poems you choose. We'll continue to read the the poetry of contemporary lawyers, and we will discuss your selections each class that we meet. You can make the poetry, and your commentary on it, part of your class portfolio of writings. You will work on this portfolio individually, and it will be a part of your final grade.
Four of the most well-known lawyer poets are: Wallace Stevens, Archibald MacLeish, Charles Reznikoff, and Edgar Lee Masters. As part of your work for the course you will be asked to choose one of the four poets, and working with a colleague (or alone if you strongly prefer), write a paper about the selected poet. The paper will constitute 50% of your grade for the course. In order to determine which of the poets you want to work with, you'll need to begin to familiarize yourself with the four poets. The way to begin is to peruse the webpages I've constructed for each of the poets on the website, Strangers to Us All: Lawyers and Poetry. I have selected these four poets, not because they are the best lawyer poets in American history (although Wallace Stevens is acclaimed as a great poet), but because they are each, in their own way, relatively well-known in poetry and literary circles. Another reason to focus on these four poets is that we have significant biographies of three of the poets (Stevens, MacLeish, Masters) and autobiographical writings by all four. There is also a good deal of scholarly literary work about all four, Stevens foremost among them. The four poets are dramatically different in regards to the poetry they wrote, the way they lived their lives, how they dealt with being lawyers, and their personality. They are interesting men, men worth knowing, men worth thinking about. When deciding which of the poets you want to work on, you'll need to peruse the links for each poet on the webpage to learn their biography and their poetry. If the materials you find on the webpage are insufficient, you should talk with the instructor, check available holdings on the poet in the library, or request books on the poet from the instructor. Note: You may find, for some reason, that you simply
cannot bear the thought of working on any of the four
selected poets. With the permission of the instructor, you can
select a poet lawyer of your own choosing. You may have someone
in mind, or find someone by way of the Strangers to Us All
website. If you do not have someone in mind, and feel the need
to work on someone other than Stevens, MacLeish, Masters, or Reznikoff,
you are invited to consider the following: I've chosen the above poets, again, not because of the overwhelming significance of their poetry, but the fact that we have interesting published biographical (and in some instances, autobiographical) information available (with perhaps the exception of Lillian Blanche Fearing, for which there is quite little available information).
Tuesday, September 5, 2006
I do not mean to suggest that what you write about the poetry you read should look like what I've undertaken. Indeed, my own efforts may take on a different focus as we proceed through the course. What I hope to do is, through the course of the semester, read all the poetry in the three LSF issues and write a longer report of that reading.
Peruse the LSF poetry issues to see if you can find poems about poetry and poets. What, if anything, do you find in the poems about poets and poetry that might help us figure out what we can do with poetry? Read the following poems on poetry, the first is a short group of poems by Archibald MacLeish and Wallace Stevens. Then read the poems by the non-lawyer poets. Which of the poems come closest, given what you understand about poetry, to say something you find interesting/intriguing/insightful about what it is poets do and what it is we might do with poetry? How do these poems about poetry help or obscure your efforts to understand poetry? Do you find anything in these poems about poetry that suggest any connections between the work of the poet and the student of your law? [Consider for example, J.K. Stephen's The Ballade of the Incompetent Ballade-Monger] Between the work of the poet and the lawyer?
September 12, 2006
You are welcome to contact any of the lawyer poets who are listed on the Strangers to Us All: Lawyers and Poetry website. I do not have the poetry from all those listed on the website, and have email and mailing addresses for some, but not all, of those who are listed. The Strangers to Us All rosters (and bios) are located at:
Law/lawyer-related Poetry in Legal Studies Forum, vol. 28 (2004) Greg Hobbs, "You Put Your Noodle (p. 84) Lawrence Russ, "Found Objects" (pp. 188-189) Paul Homer, "Lament" (p. 247), "Summary Judgment" (p. 255), "A Statutorily Protected Class" (p. 263), "A Literary Guide to Advanced Legal Writing" (p. 275), "Draft of a Lease" (p. 281), "The Lease" (282) Nancy A. Henry, "Baby's First Bath" (p. 305), "Wax" (pp. 307-308) David Bristol, "Judgment at Lums" (p. 388) Jendi Reiter, "1-800-DIVORCE" (pp. 35-351) John Perrault, "Palace of Justice" (p. 368) Ace Boggess, "Law School" (p. 386) Steven M. Richman, "Letters of Credit" (p. 407), "Relocation" (p. 408), "The Old Judge" (p. 410), "Opening Statement" (p. 411) Barbara B. Rollins, "The Man Child" (pp. 415-416) Richard S. Bank, "Commonwealth v. Wright, 317 A.2nd 271" (p. 417), "End of an Era" (p. 418), "PDPOM #102" (pp. 419-420), "PDPOM #21" (p. 421), "In re Grand Jury Matter 87-759" (p. 422), "Taking the Damage Out" (p. 433) Lawrence Joseph, "Curriculum Vitae" (pp. 535-536) Martín Espada, "Offerings to an Ulcerated God" (p. 551), "The Prisoners of Saint Lawrence" (p. 552), "Sing in the Voice of a God Even Atheists Can Hear" (pp. 553-554), "Tires Stacked in the Hallways of Civilization" (p. 555), "DSS Dream" (p. 556) Simon Perchik, untitled (p. 603) Greg McBride, "After Memo-Writing" (p. 661) Law/lawyer-related Poetry in Legal Studies Forum, vol. 29 (2005) Lori March, untitled (p. 273) Richard Krech, "Life on Appeal (p. 316), "In Chambers" (pp. 317-318) Katya Giritsky, "South Court" (p. 399), "On Teaching Gang Law Seminars" (p. 400) Ann Tweedy, "courtroom recess" (p. 411), "touring juvenile hall as part of the court of appeals" (p. 412) Lee Wm. Atkinson, "Pattern Killer Ensnared" (p. 415) Kenneth King, "Lawyer Dog" (pp. 419-420) Richard Bank, "Testation" (p. 421), "PDPOM #14--El Chupacabra" (p. 422) M.C. Bruce, "Abogado!" (pp. 423-424), "Miracles" (p. 425), "Singing in the Courtroom" (p. 426), "Good Morning" (p. 427), "The Jury Returns" (p. 431) Michael Sowder, "Former Attorney Offers Prayer of Thanksgiving For His New Job" (p. 477) Paul Homer, "Informed Consent" (pp. 484-485), "The Trial of Joshua (a/k/a Jesus)" (pp. 488-493) Howard Gofreed, "Neighbors" (p. 500), "Apostrophe" (pp. 501-502) Evie Shockley, "the ballad of anita hill" (pp. 506-507) Ace Boggess, ". . . Like All Petitioners He Must Wait (How Many Cups of Coffee in an Hour?)" (p. 545) Law/lawyer-related Poetry in Legal Studies Forum, vol. 30 (2006): Jesse Mountjoy, "Driving to a Tax Seminar / Notre Dame, Indiana" (p. 364) David Leightty, "Off the Record" (p. 380), "The Courthouse Starlings" (p. 381), "Constitutionals" & "In the Office of an Attorney Specializing in Accident Cases" (p. 383) Richard Krech, "Premeditated Deliberated & Intentional" (p. 392) Lawrence Joseph, "The Game Changed" (pp. 480-481) Lee Robinson, "Work" (pp. 560-561), "The
Rules of Evidence" (p. 562), "Grounds for Divorce"
(pp. 563-564) Seth Abramson, "If You Ask Your Attorney to Be Concise" (p. 579) Warren Wolfson, "Eleventh Floor Lies" (p. 587), "Misplaced Blame" (p. 588) John Charles Kleefeld, "Boilerplate" (pp. 589-590) Ann Tweedy, "Events Leading up to an Afterlife Meeting Between Terri Schiavo and Manadal al-Jamadi" (p. 620) Rachel Contreni Flynn, "Poem on the Road to Depose" (p. 690), "Slip & Fall" (p. 692)
Note: The best way to read the law/lawyer-related poems in LSF is to read the legal verse and then the other poems by the same poet. (What is the relationship of the law/lawyer-related verse to the poet's other poems?)
Tuesday, September 19, 2006: Lawyer Poets Talk about Poetry and Law
A Final Reading:
Tuesday, September 26, 2006: Lawyer|Poets Read|Speak Their Poetry In-Class Audio Presentations
Tuesday, October 3, 2006:
Lawyer|Poets Read|Speak Their Poetry
In-Class Audio Presentations
Audio Presentations Available
on the Web:
"The Lost Work" | read by Garrison Keillor | The Writer's Almanac | October 18, 2005 | on-line poem & audio | note: scoll to find the Nolan poem | "The Eulegy" | read by Garrison Keillor | The Writer's Almanac | August 27, 2004 | on-line poem & audio | note: scoll to find the Nolan poem |
Web Resources: Oral
Tradition: Wikipedia | Oral
History: Wikipedia | Oral
Poetry: Wikipedia | Praise
Days for the Oral Tradition |
Basque Oral Poetry Championship |
Tuesday, October 10.
The musical program for the evening is as follows:
Lawyer|Poet|Singer|Songwriters
"Country
Matters" | Rock Weed Music | 1988/1995
|
"P.L.M.
Before You Go" | Rock Weed Recordings |
1997 (w ith Barbara Londong & Jim MacDougall)
|
"Rough
Cuts" | Rock Weed Music | 1998 | (with
Mike Rodgers) |
John Perrault,
The Ballad of Louis Wagner and Other England
Stories in Verse (Peter E. Randall, Publisher,
2003) (accompanying CD)
John Perrault
is a New Hampshire teacher, folksinger, musician,
lawyer, and Poet Laureate of Portsmouth, New
Hampshire. Perrault was raised in Maine and
graduated from Providence College in 1965. He
received his Masters degree in Political Science
from the University of New Hampshire. He taught
school for 10 years and then obtained his law
degree from Franklin Pierce Law Center. With
John Ahlgren, he formed the law partnership
of Ahlgren & Perrault in 1982. Perrault has
appeared in concerts throughout New England
singing his ballads. His music albums include:
Thief in the Night (1977), New
Hampshire (1981), Tenants in Common
(1984), Country Matters (1988), Country
Matters (1995), PLM: Before You Go
(1997) [Source: Personal communication with
John Perrault]
Perrault's poetry
has appeared in the Christian Science Monitor,
Commonwealth, Key West Review,
and Poet Lore. His first published collection
of verse, The Ballad of Louis Wagner: &
Other New England Stories in Verse was published
in 2003 by Peter E. Randall, Publisher. Perrault's
latest collection of poetry, Here Comes
the Old Man Now was published by Oyster
River Press in 2005.[Source: Ballad
of the Barrister & Personal communication
with John Perrault] [Barrister
Balladeer--New Hamphsire Public Radio]
"sub
urban poet: the lawyer songs"
| gorgeous giant music/BMI | 2003
Folkpop
songstress Stephanie Haffner sings
about boys, girls, coffee, anxiety,
redevelopment, suburbia, rock-n-roll
& all manner of real life, along
her guitar work. Haffner started
composing songs when she walked
the "99 acres" between the Gallup
New Mexico school bus stop and home,
singing to herself. She started
writing songs during a break from
studies at UC Berkeley's Boalt Hall
school of law, and began singing
around the San Francisco Bay area.
After law school, she moved to Stockton,
and began contributing to the Stockton
and Sacramento music scenes while
holding down her day job as a legal
aid lawyer. In 2003 she released
the self-produced CD, 'Sub Urban
Poet: the Lawyer Songs,' a minimalist,
solo, political, acoustic-electric-spoken
word follow-up to the acoustic lovelorn
pop of her 2001 debut, 'Are You
the One?' In 2004, Haffner relocated
to Southern California where she
dropped out of law practice and
singing and took up law school teaching.
She has now resumed the practice
of law and supervises the housing/consumer
unit of Neighborhood Legal Services
of Los Angeles County.
Haffner
informs us: "My City (the mayor's
song) was written around 2 a.m.
while working out the theory of
the case in a motion for preliminary
injunction for Price v. City
of Stockton, a redevelopment
suit that resulted in a published
opinion at 390 F.2d 1105 (9th Cir.
2004). Hallelujah reflects on the
circumstances of the same case--months
after winning a preliminary injunction
that ordered Stockton to stop using
code enforcement as an excuse to
shutter residential hotels &
displace their residents unless
it also gave substantial relocation
assistance. Of course, the injunction
did not stop all the closures (though
it did halt some)--or other run-the-bums-out
measures." [Personal communication,
Stephanie Haffner, October 7, 2006]
"2nd Help of Chicken
Soup for the Lawyers's Soul" | LawSongs,
Inc | 1999 |
Tuesday, October 31:
Class Presentations: Edgar
Lee Masters
Archibald MacLeish
Tuesday, Nov. 7. Election Day. No Class
Wednesday, Nov. 8. Class
will meet with our guest, Michael Blumenthal
Tuesday, November 13:
Class Presentations :: Wallace Stevens &
John William Corrington
Wallace Stevens:
John William Corrington:
Tuesday, November 21. Thanksgiving Break. No Class
Tuesday, November 27.
Class Presentation: Charles Reznikoff
|