Lawyers | Poets | Poetry

Professor James R. Elkins
College of Law
:: West Virginia University
Fall, 2006


Thinking About Poetry

Introduction

Bill Zavatsky, "Everything You Always Wanted to Know About Poetry" [on-line text] [an earlier version of the essay appeared in Bill Zavatsky & Ron Padgett (eds.), The Whole Word Catalogue 2 (Teachers & Writers Collaborative, 1976, 1999)]

What Makes for Bad Poetry? (In contrast, what makes for a bad legal brief?)

In preparation for your response to this question, read:

Locate one of your law school legal writings, preferably a legal brief, and see if you can determine, by way of your reading of poetry, how the language in the brief falters.

Obscurity in Poetry

A Lucidist Manifesto & Decalogue

Poetry and Private Language

On Intellectual Obscurity in Poetry

The Mystique of the Difficult Poem

How Much Does a Reader of Poetry Need to Know About the Formal Elements of Poetry?

Compare with law: civil and criminal procedure (we teach criminal law before we teach criminal procedure; until recent years, we did not teach civil procedure in the first semester of the lst year and some of us continue to hold to the antiquated notion that it is a mistake to teach the course in the 1st semester today). We teach law without teaching the rules of statutory construction, or the rules we associate with starae decisis. We teach corporations and securities law without sending you first to get an MBA; we teach law and psychiatry and students in that course may never have had a psychology course. We teach tax law and do not require you to have had an accounting course.

As background reading for this question, you might begin by perusing the following guides to poetry:

Poetry and Why We Don't Read It, Don't Know Anything About It, and Assume We Can Live Perfectly Well Without It

Dana Gioia, "Can Poetry Matter?" [on-line text] [originally published in The Atlantic Monthly, 1991] [Dana Gioia]

Bart Baxter, "Does Poetry Matter? The Culture of Poetry"
[The Raven Chronicles]
[on-line text]

John Olson, Forum: "Does Poetry Matter?"
[The Raven Chronicles]
[on-line text]

Melanie Rehak, Poetry Nation? The Favorite Poem Project
[Salon] [on-line text]

Donald Hall, "Death to the Death of Poetry" [Harpers Magazine, 1989] [on-line text] [Donald Hall]

Joseph Brodsky, "An Immodest Proposal" [address was delivered at the Library of Congress, October 1991; from On Grief and Reason: Essays (New York: Farrar, Straus & Giroux, 1995)] [on-line text] [Joseph Brodsky]

Locating Poetry as One of the Humanities

Harold Bloom, "They have the numbers; we, the heights"
[Boston Review, 1998] [on-line text]

Marjorie Perloff, "In Defense of Poetry"
[Boston Review, 2000] [on-line text]

Locating Poetry in Its History

Life Studies: American Poetry from T. S. Eliot to Allen Ginsberg
[The Academy of American Poets]

R.S. Gwynn, "A Field Guide to the Poetics of the '90s" [1995] [on-line text]

Thomas Love Peacock (1785-1866), "The Four Ages of Poetry" [1820] [on-line text]

The Poetess in America
[Annie Finch, Critical Issue, Able Muse, 2002]

What's Wrong With Contemporary Poetry

The Found Poem (An Introduction to Charles Reznikoff)

Ron Padgett, "Gimmicks" [on-line text] [Ron Padgett] [Homepage]

Home